REVIEW: The Talented Mr Ripley, Grand Opera House, York, until Saturday ****

Bruce Herbelin-Earle’s Dickie Greenleaf, left, and Ed McVey’s Tom Riley in The Talented Mr Ripley. Picture: Mark Senior

“HAVE you ever thought you are being watched,” asks Ed McVey’s Tom Ripley, the nobody who wants to be someone else, someone more, at the outset of director Mark Leipacher’s new stage adaptation of The Talented Mr Ripley.

As it turns out, the obsessive, evasive, elusive chameleon Ripley is being watched by everyone: not only the audience and the Italian police, but also by Leipacher’s interpretation of novelist Patricia Highsmith’s Eumenides (the Furies of Greek mythology): imaginary figures in pursuit of the haunted Ripley in the book’s closing pages that here become the physical manifestation of his fears, paranoia, guilt and conscience.

Leipacher, however, does not leave their entry to the latter stages of Highsmith’s psycho-drama on the Amalfi Coast in 1950s’ Italy. Instead, from the off, they become a crew filming, editing and interjecting into Ripley’s writing, re-writing and telling of his story as a film, as truth, alternative truth and lies elide.  Amid the restless flow, they transform into Italian denizens and the paparazzi too, flashing their cameras in trilby and raincoat tradition.

What’s more, they don’t make conventional stage entries, but appear as if by sleight of hand as Leipacher maximises the deceptive impact of Holly Pigott’s raised set, behind which Leipacher’s players can “hide” and suddenly pop up.

In its centre is a hole, from which myriad characters appear and disappear, as well as evoking a swimming pool or a boat on the sea. Such is the minimalist theatrical flair of a postmodern production that places faith in imagination – always one of theatre’s prime assets – while still using such utilitarian props as a typewriter and reading light, cocktail glasses and shaker, a huge fridge, suitcases and Ripley’s improvised weaponry of an oar and an ashtray.

The raised stage’s white frame can be transformed by Zeynep Kepekli’s superb tubular neon  light design into differing shades to mirror a scene’s mood, or indeed Ripley’s state of mind, while the shiny black flooring suggests both wealth and Italian elegance, but sinister murkiness too.

Leipacher’s sleek stage version emerges in the wake of Highsmith’s 1955 novel being transferred to the silver screen by University of Hull drama graduate, tutor and playwright Anthony Minghella in 1999 and to Netflix streaming in Steven Zaillian’s eight-part monochrome series starring Andrew Scott  in 2024.

Both left an indelible impression, built on glamour, close-ups, exotic locations, erotic charge. Far from intimidated, Leipacher brings brio and bravura confidence to a meta-theatrical telling that echoes Greek tragedy, serves up both eloquence and elegance, pumps up the homo-erotica, nods to the rival world of cinema and revels in the mind games, even turning the fridge into a surprising mode of entry for Maisie Smith’s Marge Sherwood.

Maisie Smith’s Marge Sherwood: “More of a watercolour than an oil painting” in Mark Leipacher’s adaptation of The Talented Mr Ripley. Picture: Mark Senior

Aided by Pigott’s exquisite costume design, an air of dandy decadence yet desolation and destruction pervades Leipacher’s West End-bound account that is as seductive as McVey’s Ripley finds the freewheeling world of trust-fund wastrel charmer Dickie Greenleaf (Bruce Herbelin-Earle), a stylish but empty vessel idling his days away with a paintbrush and casual friendship with Smith’s writer-photographer Marge (a smaller role in every sense here).

Sent by New York shipbuilding magnate Herbert Greenleaf (Christopher Bianchi) to bring home his wayward son, instead McVey’s Ripley inveigles his way into the supremely assured social circuit of Dickie, Marge and writer Freddie Miles (Cary Crankson).

In Andrew Scott’s performance, you found yourself  wanting him to get away with his games of identity theft and murder amid the surfeit of insufferable smugness; McVey, by comparison, is more pitiful than pitiable in this liar’s psychopathic pursuits. Yet there is amusement too in his unguarded asides, a form of disdainful running commentary that recalls Shakespeare’s Richard III in its bravado and is a particular delight of Leipacher’s arch script, heard by the audience but not those around him, adding to his facility for deceit.

Like Banquo or Hamlet’s father, the departed do not exit stage left in Leipacher’s play, and so we see rather more of Herbelin-Earle’s handsome, lithe Dickie than might be expected, appearing on occasion as the deeper-voiced double to Ripley in adopted Dickie guise to haunt him all the more directly. The shadow of death, as it were, in an echo of Act Two opening with Ripley replicating the prone position and clothing of the dead Dickie at Act One’s close: a witty touch typical of Leipacher’s smart direction.

Best known for his Prince William in The Crown, McVey delivers a more complex characterisation here in an outstanding lead performance, ever present yet ever distant, while Herbelin-Earle, entitled yet still charming, is Dickie to the privileged New York manner born.

In her first American stage role, Strictly Come Dancing finalist and EastEnders’ soap star Smith’s smart, intuitive, independent Marge is not so well served by Leipacher’s balance of focus, more of a watercolour than an oil painting, when the role warrants a weightier significance.

Overall, however, after book, film and TV series, The Talented Mr Ripley finds its voice and style anew on stage in Leipacher’s sly, visually alluring, mentally agitated, verbally adroit coup de theatre.

The Talented Mr Ripley, Grand Opera House, York, until Saturday, 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Wednesday and Saturday matinees. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.

Maisie Smith takes on first American role as Marge Sherwood in The Talented Mr Ripley, on tour at Grand Opera House, York

“Marge was ahead of her time,” says Maisie Smith, who plays the American writer and photographer in The Talented Mr Ripley. Picture: Mark Senior

THE press release for The Talented Mr Ripley’s visit to the Grand Opera House, York, ends with this question: how far would you go to become someone else?

In the case of the acting world, the answer is the whole way for every change of role. For Maisie Smith that means transforming into Marge Sherwood – the character portrayed by Gwyneth Paltrow in  Anthony Minghella’s 2000 film and Dakota Fanning in the 2024 Netflix series – in Mark Leipacher’s touring production. Next stop, Grand Opera House, York, from January 19 to 24.

“I was so, so intrigued when the role came through and it’s very different to any character I’ve played,” says Maisie, who last appeared on a Yorkshire stage as Fran in her musical theatre debut in Strictly Ballroom The Musical at Leeds Grand Theatre in July 2023.

“This time it was a very quick process, at very short notice. I was asked, ‘could you read a scene from the script – and you can pick the scene’. I did it on tape, filming myself when I was on holiday at the time, on a fishing trip with my boyfriend in a little lake cabin.”

Not the ideal audition scenario, especially when Maisie had to evoke living in “the sun-drenched glamour of 1950s’ Italy”. “I was in this wooden cabin, in Shropshire, and I had to drive into the nearest high street to get an internet connection! It’s such a glamorous lifestyle, as they say!”

Nevertheless, the self-tape worked and the role of Marge was hers. “That was in maybe June/July last year, and we started rehearsals in August. The tour began last September [at Cheltenham Everyman Theatre, marking the 70th anniversary of Patricia Highsmith’s novel], and we’ve just had a few weeks off [since November 22] for a Christmas break,” says Maisie. “Our first week back is in York.”

Director Mark Leipacher has adapted Highsmith’s psychological thriller for its first major UK tour, casting The Crown star Ed McVey as dangerously charismatic antihero Tom Ripley, who is scraping by in New York, forging signatures, telling little white lies, until a chance encounter changes everything.

When a wealthy stranger offers him an all-expenses-paid trip to Italy to bring home his wayward son, Dickie Greenleaf (Bruce Herbelin-Earle), Tom leaps at the opportunity. However, surrounded by shimmering waters and whispered secrets on the Amalfi Coast, he is seduced by the freedom, wealth and effortless charm of Dickie’s life.

As fascination turns to obsession and his grip tightens on Dickie’s world, the lines between truth and deception begin to blur in Highsmith’s tale of deception, desire and deadly ambition. What starts as an innocent opportunity spirals into a chilling game of lies, identity theft, and murder. 

Maisie has seen the film and the monochrome TV series, but not read the read the book. “I feel a bad actress for not reading it, but I have seen the director’s notes that he wrote years ago as this play has been in the making for six years,” she says. “I couldn’t believe it when Mark said he’d been working on it for so long.”

Maisie Smith’s Marge Sherwood and Bruce Herbelin-Earle’s Dickie Greenleaf in The Talented Mr Ripley. Picture: Mark Senior

Assessing the role of Marge, she says: “I see her as a really interesting character in this play. What I love about her and what I try to drill into is that she is one of the only people who is suspicious and recognises Tom Ripley for what he is, so she’s very valuable person in the story.

“It’s a story that’s ahead of its time because she was ahead of her time: she’s very independent; she’s a writer and photographer and has her own house in Italy. She has a boyfriend but is not in a committed relationship, which was really futuristic for a woman at that time.

“That’s why this story has been told again and again over 70 years because it’s never dated and will never go out of style.”

Marge is new territory for 24-year-old Maisie. “I haven’t played an American before, and the oldest era I’d played before this was Strictly Ballroom, set in the 1980s. Lots of characters I play are of a more juvenile age. Like Tiffany [Butcher], my character in EastEnders, was  only a couple of years younger than me,” she says.

“Tiffany was quite cocky, cheeky, whereas Marge is very intelligent – and I’ve really had to rein in my Southend accent! Once I got the part, they brought in someone to work on the accent with me as Marge has this old-school American accent.”

Maisie, you may recall, finished as a finalist in the 2020 series of Strictly Come Dancing, recorded under Covid conditions. “It was so crazy but I was 19, so I think, looking back on it, it was the first time I’d ever done live TV, and the first time I’d ever been Maisie, rather than playing a character, and I did find the whole experience nerve-wracking,” she says.

“I wish I hadn’t stressed about everything – did people like me; did I do that dance right? – but then I thought, ‘no, just be yourself, who cares what people think!”

She continued to play Tiffany for another year, “but I was itching to do theatre”, a change of tack that has been rewarded with significant roles in Strictly Ballroom and now The Talented Mr Ripley. “This new character, Marge, is the most different from me. Everything about her is different from me. It’s always  a challenge but that’s what you want.”

Hence Maisie will keep asking herself that question: how far would you go to become someone else?

The Talented Mr Ripley, Grand Opera House, York, January 19 to 24, 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Wednesday and Saturday matinees. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.