
The cover artwork for Carnaval de Luz, U2’s 16th studio album and first since 2017’s Songs Of Experience
HALF a century into a career that has made their mythology as imposing as their music, U2 return sounding less like elder statesmen of rock than four precocious newcomers determined to make their mark.
Featherlight pop punctuated by robo-rock riffs, shimmering synthesisers and Bono’s soaring falsetto—surely now an instrument in its own right—makes for an exhilarating collision of the ethereal and the industrial.
This is no exercise in nostalgia. Where Songs Of Experience wrestled with foreboding and the gathering darkness, Carnaval de Luz appears determined to illuminate it on the Dublin band’s first studio album in nine years.
Edge’s metallic interventions lend muscle to melodies that might otherwise float off into the ether, while Larry Mullen Jr., adapting his inimitable rhythmic licks to a new post-injury approach, cracks open the songs in unexpected ways. Necessity, it seems, has become the mother of invention.
On Mirror Maker, Adam Clayton’s liquid bassline supplies irresistible momentum; Glorify is shot through with warm electronica, its synthetic textures glowing with melodic possibility as the lyrics reveal a halting dialogue with God.
But The Greatest Show On Earth provides perhaps the album’s most affecting sleight of hand. What initially sounds like a goodbye gradually reveals itself as a proposal to gather the broken pieces of a relationship and move on. Not resignation, then, but renewal, done the Bono way: braggadocio, bombast and enough hidden beauty to perhaps persuade even his most ardent bovine bashers that he might be onto something.
If that’s the case, then their greatest obstacle may now be their own reputation. For a band routinely dismissed as an overblown monument to its former glory, Carnaval de Luz is a refulgent rebuttal.
Were this the debut album of an unknown band, it might reasonably be hailed as a game changer. That it comes from U2 ought not diminish the achievement. If anything, it makes it all the more remarkable.
Review by Greg McGee, director of According To McGee (www.accordingtomcgee.com) and New Visuality (https://newvisuality.wordpress.com/), artist and photographer
