On terror alert to the max: James Bye’s James and Hannah Sinclair Robinson’s Lou in Paranormal Activity. Picture: Johan Persson
WHEN Paranormal Activity premiered at Leeds Playhouse in August 2024, the Playhouse website stated: “American couple James and Lou move to London to escape their past…we can’t say anything else.”
Obviously, a review has to say rather more than that, but the Playhouse poster’s instruction of “Shhh! No spoilers” remains pertinent two years later, even if Punchdrunk theatre director Felix Barrett’s immersive account of American playwright Levi Holloway’s self-contained offshoot from the movie franchise has since enjoyed a hit West End run at the Ambassadors Theatre.
Now the Melting Pot, Simon Friend and Hanna Osnolska touring production is in its early weeks, visiting York, the city that trades as the most haunted in Europe.
“Good horror is personal,” reads the headline in blood-red capitals to introduce writer Holloway’s programme note. “Good horror doesn’t rob you of your sleep, it rules it,” he writes. When the house lights go out, there are people waiting for you in the dark, he declares. “Later, when you try to bed down, when you close your eyes and the dark comes again, you know who to blame.”
Rest far from assured, when your reviewer wended his way to bedfordshire, the landing light remained on all night and no internal doors were closed.
The senses had been scrambled and fried by encountering Paranormal Activity, whose late opening – delayed by 15 minutes on opening night – only heightened the tension. Once Nirvana’s Lithium kicked in at deafening decibels, there would be no escape from sound designer Gareth Fry’s aural assaults, Barrett’s directorial sleights of hand, Anna Watson’s restless lighting and the tricks of the eye of Chris Fisher’s illusion designs that not even the interval could assuage.
The audience is cast into deepest darkness before that Lithium cacophony, an instantly unsettling feeling, whereupon we are invited to take in the full scope of Fly Davis’s two-storey house design: downstairs, an open-plan kitchen-cum-sitting room and dining area; upstairs, the main bedroom, a bathroom, and in between another bedroom, bare now, but potentially a child’s room, should newly-weds James (James Bye) and Lou (Hannah Sinclair Robinson), newly arrived in London from Chicago, make plans.
The stairway will be in constant use in horror movie tradition, and the profusion of doors may be more befitting of a farce, but Paranormal Activity is no laughing matter, albeit it that it starts that way with James (or Jimmy as everyone calls him) and Lou in playful mood, captured in the freedom of movement given to the actors by the director deliberately not “blocking” the opening scenes in rehearsal.
However, we know that the couple have left the USA to “escape their past”, and already the pipes are making funny noises, the lights and the television are playing up, and soon we learn that Lou is on medication for depression. The laughter starts to look nervously over its shoulder.
Each scene ends with being plunged into darkness, the black-out accompanied by the screech or hiss of distorted industrial sound, as deliberately disorientating as interrogation techniques, before the next scene opens with a heightened sense of blind terror,
Bye is appearing in his second psychological thriller of the year at the Grand Opera House after playing opinionated scientist Sam in Danny Robins’s 2:22 A Ghost Story in April. If that play was as much a commentary on the changing culture of living in modern-day London as a ghost story, booted with telegraphed jump scares, Paranormal Activity is not as socially savvy or quick-witted, but it lays its traps with greater subtlety, cranking up the nerve-shredding with delicious timing while consistently adding new layers of mystery, then shredding them before the devastating final revelations.
Jo Castleton’s spiritualist, Etheline Cotgrave, and Caroline Faber’s Carolanne, James’s hyper-religious mother, add to the intrigue, and as the surprises and the scares mount up, Bye and Sinclair Robinson (last seen in York in Frantic Assembly’s Lost Atoms last October) fray at the edges as the couple disintegrates. The truth will out, the theatrical magic will ramp up, and you won’t experience a louder play in York this year.
One word of warning: it has come to your reviewer’s attention that according to one colleague “visibility was heavily restricted from further back in the Grand Circle, where the overhang from the ceilings on the set meant that you couldn’t see the actors’ faces unless they were in the front half of the set”. Bear that in mind when booking.
Paranormal Activity, Grand Opera House, York, no sleep until Saturday; performances at 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Saturday matinee. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.
Gripping scene: James Bye’s James and Hannah Sinclair Robinson’s Lou in Paranormal Activity. Picture: Johan Persson
JAMES Bye is making a habit of spooking theatre audiences in York, the city that trades as “the most haunted in Europe”.
In April he played self-righteous, hyper-opinionated, sceptical but irritatingly always-right scientist Sam in Danny Robins’s smart, modern-day London supernatural thriller 2:22 A Ghost Story.
From tonight (29/9/2026) to Saturday, he returns to the Grand Opera House to play James in Paranormal Activity, the first British and Irish tour of a new story inspired by the horror film phenomenon, scripted by Levi Holloway, the Chicago writer, director, actor and teacher behind Broadway hit Grey House, and directed by immersive theatre pioneer and Punchdrunk artistic director Felix Barrett.
When American couple James (Bye) and Lou (Hannah Sinclair Robinson, last seen in York as Jess in Frantic Assembly’s Lost Atoms at the Theatre Royal) move from Chicago to London to escape their past, soon they discover that rather than places being haunted, people are.
“York is a fantastic city to host this show,” says James. “We’ll fit right in here! I think a theatre [building] definitely brings another dynamic to a performance, and we’re fortunate to be visiting some of the older theatres in the country on this tour. York [the Grand Opera House] is one of the oldest, and everyone will lean into that.”
Who…or what’s there? James Bye’s James in the doorway in Paranormal Activity. Picture: Johan Persson
As he prepares to return to York, how would James compare Paranormal Activity with 2:22 A Ghost Story? “For people who have not seen either or have seen 2:22 and are thinking about coming to Paranormal Activity, I would say 2:22 leans more towards being a thriller with jump scares, whereas with Paranormal Activity what we’re trying to achieve is straight-out old-school horror, where we want the audience to be on the edge of their seats,” says James.
“Not that we don’t want them to enjoy it but we really want to scare them, but it’s done in a more subtle way than in 2:22. This play has a very naturalistic style that is more like television, where the audience feel like they’re in the room with us.”
James continues: “The set design by Fly Davis in incredible: it’s an actual two-storey house, like a doll’s house, with a bedroom, empty bedroom and bathroom upstairs, stairs, and an open-plan kitchen and living area downstairs. We use the whole house, which is lit throughout, which really helps to bring the audience into the ‘room’.
“The audience will see the set before they see any actors and they all just love it! Their breath is taken away before we do anything.”
James joined the tour cast on the back of Paranormal Activity’s hit West End run at the Ambassadors Theatre. “I was asked if I wanted to see it, but I very deliberately said ‘No’ as I didn’t want to copy something subconsciously when it’s such a rich piece in its own right and it becomes very much my own creation,” he says.
James Bye’s Sam takes a vote on a point of debate with Shvorne Marks’s Jenny, Natalie Casey’s Lauren and Grant Kilburn’s Ben in 2:22 A Ghost Story, on tour at Grand Opera House, York, in April 2026
“It’s one of those shows that’s right up the audience’s street. It’s in the horror genre, but very funny too, keeping them entertained with comedy but then flipping it on its head, so the scares are for real.
“This is the challenge: doing something scary on stage while keeping the audience with you. which the director [Felix Barrett] has done brilliantly, blurring the line between 2D and theatre.
“The show absolutely has a cinematic element to it, and that’s very deliberate. We definitely want the audience to lean into that.”
Describing his American character in Paranormal Activity, James says: “He’s like a Labrador: high energy, always fun, trying to make his wife laugh all the time. They’re newly married, they’ve just moved to the UK and they’re super-happy together. He needs her so much and leans on her so much too.
“Then there’s another character, Jimmy’s mum, who’s still in America, so they have moments where they Zoom-call. He’s just a fun-loving guy, but as it progresses, you learn more about him and Lou, and maybe they’re not as much in love as we first thought. Maybe they’re not squeaky clean; maybe they’re living a lie with each other.”
The poster for the 2026 tour of Paranormal Activity
Praising Levi Holloway’s script, James says: “It’s so well crafted: the way the audience laugh genuinely at the start, but then there’s a pitch change, where it becomes nervous laughter. I don’t think I’ve ever been in a show where the audience has been so vocal.
“It’s lovely to get that response from the audience, and I would ask anyone who’s thinking of coming to the show to feel they can vocalise their response , as we’re going on a journey together. You can really embrace being in a room together where it feels like more of an experience.
“Levi brings this super-naturalistic style to the play, where I couldn’t put the script down when I read it. It’s like a work of art how he takes you through the story, one minute making you laugh, the next, sob. I don’t have to force anything. I just have to trust it.”
James is working with Punchdrunk artistic director Felix Barrett for the first time. “It’s very naturalistic style, where a lot of time was spent on thinking about how does fear go through me, how does it affect me, and then the complete opposite: joy. How does joy affect me? It’s very freeing to be able to work like that.
“A lot of time was spent on thinking about how does fear go through me, how does it affect me, and then the complete opposite: joy. How does joy affect me? It’s very freeing to be able to work like that, working on getting into an emotional state, where it’s all about being in the moment.”
What awaits James Bye’s James on the other side of the door? Find out at the Grand Opera House from tonight until Saturday. Picture: Johan Persson
James continues: “The first scene between Jimmy and Lou, which takes up the majority of Act One, is not blocked, so every night has been different. Sometimes Hannah and I just so playful because they’re such a super-fun couple. When we started, that could be quite scary, but we always trusted each other.
“Then there are parts of the play where it’s very specific that things have to happen at a certain time.”
Paranormal Activity, Grand Opera House, York, tonight (29/9/2026) to Saturday, 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Wednesday and Saturday matinees. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.
Did you know?
JAMES Bye played market trader Martin Fowler in the BBC One soap opera EastEnders from December 5 2014 to February 20 2025. The long-running character was killed off in a special live episode for the show’s 40th anniversary, dying of a cardiac arrest after a steel beam crushed him during an explosion at the Queen Victoria pub.
He competed in series 20 of BBC One’s Strictly Come Dancing in 2022, reaching Week 6, Halloween Week, when he and professional partner Amy Dowden were the fifth couple to be eliminated, beaten in the October 30 dance-off by Fleur East and Vito Coppola.
“Maybe they’re not as much in love as we first thought,” says James Bye. “Maybe they’re not squeaky clean; maybe they’re living a lie with each other.” Picture: Johan Persson
Bread & Circuses, by Sarah Hall Baqai, from her exhibition at Rise@Bluebird Bakery, Acomb
FROM the terrors of Paranormal Activity to circus art and entertainment, Tony Blackburn’s Sixties’ celebration to the debut York Jazz Fest, Charles Hutchinson heads into a fruitful autumn.
Exhibition opening of the week: Sarah Hall Baqai, Bread & Circuses, Rise@Bluebird Bakery, Acomb Road, Acomb, York, until November 19
YORK artist Sarah Hall Baqai’s new collection of artworks has the theme of Bread & Circuses, a phrase taken from Roman poet Juvenal’s work Satire X, written in 100AD. In a nutshell, “give them bread and circuses and they will never revolt”, on account of being distracted.
Distraction does not come brighter and more entertaining visually than Sarah’s paintings inspired by life behind the scenes at the circus (from her work with Gifford’s Circus and Fools Delight Circus at Ham Court, Bampton), complemented by lettering and graphic work celebrating York Minster and willow lanterns in the shape of jugglers’ sticks.
Russells International Circus: Intent on delivering in-tent entertainment on Knavesmire this weekend
While on the subject of circuses: Russells International Circus, Knavesmire, York, today, 3pm and 6pm, and tomorrow, 12 noon
ROLL up, roll up, as Russells International Circus, voted Britain’s best circus six years running, brings its new show for 2026 to York. Each two-hour performance is jam-packed with mesmerising aerial displays, jaw-dropping stunts, comedy and more besides. Box office: russellscircus.co.uk.
The Jake Leg Jug Band: Songs of murder, betrayal, gambling, liquor and redemption at Kirk Theatre, Pickering
Ragtime gig of the week: The Jake Leg Jug Band, Kirk Theatre, Pickering, tonight, 7.30pm
THE Jake Leg Jug Band delivers the authentic sounds of 1920s and 1930s’ America – jazz, blues, ragtime and gospel – in songs of murder, betrayal, gambling, liquor and redemption.
Since self-releasing debut album Cotton Mouth, Duncan Wilcox, vocals and double bass, and Warren James, vocals, guitar and banjo, have released a further eight albums in 12 years, among them Next Stop!, Everythin’s Jake, Break A Leg, Fifth Avenue, Goodbye Booze, Hello Central and 2024’s spirituals collection Some Glad Morning. Box office: kirktheatre.co.uk.
Thompson Twins’ Tom Bailey: Heading to York Barbican tonight
Eighties’ double bill of the week: Thompson Twins’ Tom Bailey and Blancmange, York Barbican, tonight, doors 6.30pm
REMEMBER the Thompson Twins, makers of such 1980s’ hits as Hold Me Now, Doctor Doctor, In the Name Of Love, Love On Your Side, If You Were Here, Lies, Lay Your Hands On Me and King For A Day? Tom Bailey, the Sheffield-founded group’s lead vocalist and instrumentalist, now performs under the name Thompson Twins’ Tom Bailey, revisiting his past and showcasing debut solo album Science Fiction.
Tonight he closes his autumn tour at York Barbican, the only Yorkshire location on his 14-date itinerary, when fellow 1980s’ chart act Blancmange support. Box office: yorkbarbican.co.uk.
Hannah Sinclair Robinson’s Lou and James Bye’s James on terror alert on the stairs in Paranormal Activity, on tour at Grand Opera House, York. Picture: Johan Persson Credit: Johan Persson
Psychological thriller of the week: Paranormal Activity, Grand Opera House, York, September 29 to October 3, 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Wednesday and Saturday matinees
IN a new story inspired by the worldwide horror phenomenon, Paranormal Activity is directed by immersive theatre pioneer and Punchdrunk artistic director Felix Barrett and written by Levi Holloway, the playwright behind Broadway hit Grey House.
When James (James Bye) and Lou (Hannah Sinclair Robinson) move from Chicago to London to escape their past, soon they discover that places are not haunted, but people are. Can you hold your nerve in the face of this chilling production on its first British and Irish tour? Box office: atgtickets.com/york.
Sounds Of The 60’s Live: Sensational Sixties show at York Barbican
Sixties’ celebration of the week: Sounds Of The 60’s Live, hosted by Tony Blackburn, York Barbican, September 29, 7.30pm
BBC Radio 2 presenter Tony Blackburn hosts an evening of stories and songs from “perhaps the most iconic ten years in music, fashion and popular culture” on the Sounds Of The 60’s tour, 62 years since his first broadcast on pirate radio station Radio Caroline South in 1964.
The Sounds Of The 60’s All Star Band and Singers perform hits by The Everly Brothers, Elvis Presley, The Drifters, Marvin Gaye, a Rolling Stones medley, The Walker Brothers, Diana Ross & The Supremes, The Beatles, The Beach Boys, Stevie Wonder and more besides. Box office: yorkbarbican.co.uk.
Roham Bayat’s poster design for the four-day York Jazz Fest
Festival of the week: York Jazz Fest, October 1 to 4
BEPPE Lombardo, soprano saxophone player in his Italian teenage days and supremo of Trinicria Sicilian Ristorante in Bishopthorpe Road for 15 years, is running the inaugural York Jazz Fest with funding from York and North Yorkshire Combined Authority Mayor David Skaith.
Angel On The Green, York Arts Barge, Young Thugs Studio, the Phoenix Inn and The Winning Post play host to concerts on the first three days, culminating in the Bishopthorpe Road Car Park Finale next Sunday, topped off by sets by Dennis Rollins’ Funky-Funk and Ian Chalk. For full listings and tickets, go to: yorkjazzfestival.com.
Katy Cawkwell in the poster for Lilith at Rise@Bluebird Bakery
“Shocking, seductive and entertaining” show of the week: Katy Cawkwell in Lilith, Rise@Bluebird Bakery, Acomb, York, October 1, 8.30pm
BEFORE Eve, there was Lilith, as revealed in Katy Cawkwell’s uplifting one-woman storytelling showin an exploration and celebration of female power through the mythological figure of Adam’s first wife.
Lilith was not prepared to lie down and accept what was given to her. Thrown out of Eden, she slithered back in to take her revenge and wake up Eve to what her body could do.
“Viewed as a demon, worshipped as a goddess, adored as the Queen of Sheba, Lilith slips out of the Bible, reclaims the narrative and is dancing with us still, forever free,” says Cawkwell, who mixes myth from Arabia, Ethiopia, Mesopotamia and Jewish tradition with a dash of feminist flavouring and a large dollop of her own wild dreaming. Box office: bluebirdbakery.co.uk/rise.
Ben Portsmouth: Presenting This Is Elvis with the Taking Care Of Elvis Band at York Barbican
Tribute gig of the week: Ben Portsmouth: This Is Elvis, York Barbican, October 2, 7.30pm
REGARDED as the “closest living performer to the legendary Elvis Presley”, Ben Portsmouth has enjoyed success in more than 20 countries and became the first European to be crowned by Elvis Presley Enterprises as the Worldwide Ultimate Elvis Tribute Artist in Memphis in 2012.
This Is Elvis takes an immersive journey through Presley’s greatest hits from his rockabilly roots to the dazzling Las Vegas years in the company of Portsmouth and the Taking Care Of Elvis Band. Box office: yorkbarbican.co.uk.
In Focus: Say Owt Slam, featuring Kirsty Taylor and KG, The Crescent, York, tonight, 7.30pm to 10pm
Bradford writer and educator Kirsty Taylor. Picture: Carolyn Mendelsohn
SAY Owt, York’s loveable gang of loveable gang of performance poets, brings the best working-class poets and rappers from Bradford tonight to complement the Say Owt Slam clash of the verbals.
“Since 2014, we’ve hosted high-energy nights of words and verse, bringing together poets, musicians, spoken-word artists, rappers and anyone with a story to tell,” says artistic director Henry Raby.
“We’re always proud of our line-ups, but this could be our most exciting parade of poets yet. It wouldn’t be possible without buzzy audiences showing up and being loud and demanding more and more shows! And it wouldn’t be a Say Owt season without a poetry slam!”
Henry continues: “Say Owt Slam is an energetic battle of words where judges in the audience score the poets and the top-scoring poet is crowned Say Owt Slam champion at the end of the night. Tonight, as well as a top crop of York poets, we have slammers from Glasgow, Manchester and Halifax hoping to win the competition.”
Kemmi Gill: Rapper, poet and youth worker
Tonight’s bill also features two guests from guests from Bradford, Kirsty Taylor and KG (Kemmi Gill). “Kirsty is a writer and educator inspired by her beloved home city of Bradford,” says Henry. “She is passionate about storytelling through poetry and has performed all over the country telling tales about people, class and the realities of Broken Britain.”
Taylor was a BBC Verb New Voice in 2017 and was awarded the Apples and Snakes & Jerwood Arts Poetry in Performance award in 2020. She is the creator of Front Room Poetry, which takes nanna-style living rooms and world-class poets to unusual settings such as car parks and housing estates.
Kirsty opened Bradford’s year as UK City of Culture 2025 in January last year when she performed her words to 20,000 people over the first weekend.
KG (Kemmi Gill) is a Bradford-born rapper, poet and youth worker, hailed by Wordplay Magazine as “one of the sharpest lyricists” in the UK rap scene. “Kemmi combines lyrical storytelling and wordplay to explore themes of struggle and hope and has contributed writing and performance work to major civic projects, such as the open-air spectacular Rise and Common/Wealth’s sell-out show Public Interest,” says Henry.
James Bye’s Sam takes a vote on a point of debate with Shvorne Marks’s Jenny, Natalie Casey’s Lauren and Grant Kilburn’s Ben in 2:22 A Ghost Story.
THE Battersea Poltergeist and Uncanny podcaster, broadcaster and journalist Danny Robins’s smart, modern-day London supernatural thriller is haunting York once more, only 23 months since last doing so.
Is that return too soon? Tuesday’s audience could have been fuller, and a cursory inspection of the Grand Opera House box-office website reveals a similar picture for the rest of the week, but your reviewer urges those yet to encounter this Best New Play winner in the WhatsOnStage Awards to do so. In a nutshell, if you enjoy regular returnee The Woman In Black, then clock on for 2:22.
Robins’s nerve-shredder looks very much at home in Europe’s self-proclaimed “most haunted city”, but with a notable metropolitan flair to Anna Fleischle’s set design of a state-of-the-art, open-plan, glass-encased kitchen, complemented by a sleight of hand worthy of Derren Brown’s mind games, topped off by Magic Circle member Chris Fisher’s illusions.
Directors Matthew Dunster and Gabriel Vega Weissman crank up the tension pre-show with the too-quick-for-the-naked-eye turnover of numbers on the electronic kitchen clock – never stopping at 2:22 – while Ian Dickinson’s sound design grows ever louder and more discordant to heighten your senses for what lies ahead.
Throughout, Dickinson and lighting designer Lucy Carter will work those senses to the maximum with mischievous glee and a conductor’s sense of perfect timing, regularly interrupting with shocking sounds, screams, blinding lights and a framing of the proscenium arch in red light at the start of each scene. You will judder, you will shudder, you may well shriek, jolted further by the yelps of foxes doing what foxes do in the garden.
Robins combines the cultural and social commentary of James Graham’s dramas with his own canny podcast insights in his paranormal tale of teacher-on-maternity-leave Jenny (Shvorne Marks) and irritatingly always-right scientist Sam (James Bye) hosting their first dinner party since becoming the latest “posh tw*ts” to move into a newly gentrified Greater London neighbourhood.
Sam will be heading back from a work trip on the Isle of Sark. For several nights, however, Jenny has been disturbed at 2:22am precisely by the footstep thud of someone moving around the house and the sound of a man’s crying voice, picked up via the baby monitor in newborn daughter Phoebe’s bedroom. Already convinced the house is haunted, Jenny whiles away the hours each night by painting until that time arrives.
Robins, in partnership with his meticulous directors, is stirring the ingredients of a classic thriller with Hitchcockian chutzpah, just as guest Lauren (Natalie Casey), Jenny’s American psychiatrist best friend since university days, is stirring the risotto on arrival.
Lauren has brought along her latest boyfriend, house renovator Ben (Grant Kilburn) a streetwise, working-class counter to the yuppie London intellectuals, who did up her kitchen, never left and likes to wear his shoes without socks.
Last to arrive is Bye’s Sam, a self-righteous, hyper-opinionated sceptic, apologising for losing his phone on Sark but not for his sarky attitude. Whereupon these two stags lock horns in splenetic class warfare on what turns out to be Ben’s old “manor” before Sam and Jenny stripped out everything, like in every house around them that all end up with the same soulless look, says Ben, who has designed plenty of them.
Sam is a belligerent non-believer in ghosts, adamant that more logical reasons can explain the noises. Ben believes in the supernatural; tipsy Lauren could be persuaded either way. Let’s stay up to 2:22am, suggests Jenny, as the trendy wine flows, the guards drop and the arguments rise – as ultimately does the sexual heat – in an echo of the sparks flying in Edward Albee’s Who’s Afraid Of Virginia Woolf or a Tennessee Williams play, played out in performances that all catch fire.
2:22 A Ghost Story has the spooks to rival The Woman In Black, but now filtered through modern technology (the baby monitor and an erratic Alexa). Then add the razzle-dazzle to and fro of the dialogue in Robins’s state-of-the-nation character study: the choices of wine and risotto for supper; Sam’s dinner party playlist (Massive Attack) and Jenny’s too (The XX); the reference to Sam and Lauren working together for a charity in Africa.
Robins is happy for his quarrelling quartet to discuss how the lizard, mouse and monkey sections of our brain work and to reflect how fear, rather than love, is our most powerful emotion. You may well want to join that debate afterwards, once your heart rate has returned to normal.
2: 22 A Ghost Story has shocks and alarms aplenty, but above all it is uncomfortably, truthfully humorous, becoming all the spicier for the intellectual jousting that sometimes leaves the dialogue almost too hot to touch under Dunster and Weissman’s combustible direction.
Robins fills the hours until 2:22am so thrillingly, building the chills while thickening the plot with relationship revelations; setting up a debate over the existence or non-existence of ghosts; telling the Charles Lindbergh story behind the invention of the baby monitor, and orchestrating the climactic séance conducted by Ben.
You will have to see the show- and you really should – to discover the truth behind the spooks, but all the while Ben serves as a ghost of the street’s past that cannot be erased, no matter the aspirational revamp.
“Shhh, please don’t tell” requests a neon-lit message in shepherd’s-warning red after the final “reveal”. Lips sealed, note taken, review concluded.
2:22 A Ghost Story, Grand Opera House, York, until Saturday, 7.30pm nightly plus 2.30pm Saturday matinee. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.
Natalie Casey’s Lauren and James Bye’s Sam in Danny Robins’ 2:22 A Ghost Story, on tour at Grand Opera House, York, next week
THE numbers add up for metropolitan supernatural thriller 2:22 A Ghost Story. Seven West End seasons, 12 productions worldwide, one record-breaking UK and Ireland tour, now being followed by another.
Next stop, a return to the Grand Opera House, York, from March 31 to April 4 after a first spooking in Europe’s self-proclaimed “most haunted city” in May 2024.
From the imagination of The Battersea Poltergeist and Uncanny podcaster, broadcaster and journalist Danny Robins comes the paranormal tale of teacher-on-maternity-leave Jenny (Three Little Birds’ Shvorne Marks) and always-right scientist Sam (EastEnders’ James Bye) hosting their first dinner party since becoming the latest “posh tw*ts” to move into a newly gentrified Greater London neighbourhood.
For several nights, Jenny has been disturbed at 2:22am precisely by the sound of someone moving around the house and a man’s voice crying, picked up via the baby monitor in daughter Phoebe’s bedroom.
She is convinced the house is haunted, but Sam scoffs at the suggestion, sparking an argument with dinner guests Lauren (Natalie Casey), Sam’s best friend since university days, and her latest boyfriend, builder Ben (Grant Kilburn), a streetwise, working-class counter to the yuppie London intellectuals.
Can the dead really walk again? Belief and scepticism clash, but as the sudden sounds, screams and blinding lights multiply and the trendy wine flows, they will stay up until 2:22am to discover the answer in Robins’ thriller of Hitchcockian elan.
Facing up to the supernatural: James Bye, left, Shvorne Marks, Natalie Casey and Grant Kilburn in 2:22 A Ghost Story
“The thing about this show is that it’s a phenomenon,” says cast member Natalie Casey, once of Two Pints Of Lager And A Packet Of Crisps. “I’ve never been involved in anything like it. MAGA [Make America Great Again] is a cult, but 2:22 is a phenomenon. I’ve never done a show before where people scream, they cry, and it grabs them by whatever they want to be grabbed by!
“I first auditioned for it many years ago, but didn’t get it and was very sad about that, but I think I must have stayed on their radar as I was asked to do this tour – though I hadn’t toured for a long time – and got very excited when I saw who else would be doing it.
“It’s reinvigorated my love of touring, and it’s been amazing meeting people around the country, where we know that this is a time when lots is going on to divide people, when in fact all we want is to get on with our neighbours and just hug each other.”
Analysing why 2:22 is more than a supernatural thriller, Natalie says: “It’s very richly layered. On the surface it’s about the jump scares, but it’s also a play about fear, longing and our refusal as human beings to let things go when we need to.
“To be able to deliver that message to people in the dark of a theatre, where they can feel real emotions together, is an amazing feeling to get as an actor. As dark as our times are, I can feel we want better, we want more, and theatre is a magical part of that.”
Natalie’s character, Lauren, comes from California. “So I’m doing a slight ‘Valley girl’ accent – I’m good at American accents as they infect every part of our lives,” she says. “I’m playing someone who’s completely unlike me, but that’s the chameleon quality of acting, where my dream is to be in Star Trek. I’d love to play a Klingon!”
New house, old friends: James Bye’s Sam, left, and Shvorne Marks’s Jenny, right, welcome Natalie Casey’s Lauren and Grant Kilburn’s Ben for dinner in 2:22 A Ghost Story
Actress, presenter, narrator and singer Natalie feels very lucky to be on stage with James Bye, Shvorne Marks and Grant Kilburn. “It’s very easy to ramp up the tension when you have actors so committed to doing that, and immediately the house becomes very claustrophobic: that feeling of walls closing on you,” she says.
Throughout, the clock is on the move. “There is the symbolism of time, how it will inevitably pass, whether we like it or not, and how it will reveal too, whether we want it to or not,” says Natalie.
Does she believe in the supernatural? “I’m not a believer, I’m a ‘man of science’. I’ve never experienced what could be classed as ‘supernatural’ or felt it, but I also know that science takes a long time to catch up, so I would never say that anyone who has had a supernatural experience is wrong. It’s just that we’ve not yet reached the point where we can explain it,” says Natalie. “In an infinite world with infinite possibilities, there are infinite explanations.
“It’s part of our collective psyche, that obsession with what is just beyond our periphery; our need to reach out to what is just beyond our understanding. We will always look to give meaning to our world.”
Summing up 2:22 A Ghost Story, she says. “It might look like a simple piece of theatre with two couples sitting around a dinner party table, but it turns into a play about love and loss, mourning and yearning for a different life. This play will be watched for decades. This play will never die. Oh, the irony.”
2:22 A Ghost Story, Grand Opera House, York, March 31 to April 4, 7.30pm nightly plus 2.30pm Wednesday and Saturday matinees. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.
