REVIEW: By Royal Appointment, York Theatre Royal, until Saturday ***

Jane Asher as The Queen, surrounded by royal dresses on show in Daisy Goodwin’s By Royal Appointment. Picture: Robert Day

THERE has been a multitude of portraits of Elizabeth II, from Spitting Image to The Crown, Helen Mirren in The Queen to Moira Buffini’s play Handbagged.

Now comes By Royal Appointment, the debut play by Daisy Goodwin, creator of ITV’s historical television drama series Victoria.

The novel spin here is that By Royal Appointment is as much the story of The Dresser (played by Laura Main), The Designer (David Robb) and The Milliner (Matthew Cottle) as it is a depiction of The Queen (theatre royalty Jane Asher). More to the point, it is the story of how The Queen’s clothes spoke volumes for her.

Unfortunately, the words now wrapped around that statement are stiff and awkward, reduced in impact by their methodical, metronomic, repetitious, monotone rhythm and a chronological structure led by Laura Matthews’ Curator/narrator that undermines momentum. 

No amount of high-quality acting and droll humour can save By Royal Appointment from feeling underwhelming, especially by comparison with the wit and political commentary of Buffini’s Handbagged, with its heavyweight clash between The Queen and Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher in younger and older years.

Handbagged still covered the passing years, but was more concentrated in its focus, whereas Goodwin’s play spans 1969 to 2022, opening and closing with The Dresser, Gigi Gaunt’s attendance at The Queen’s Funeral and taking an episodic format, where Matthews’ Curator introduces each scene with a snapshot of that year’s cultural highlights.

By Royal Appointment is based loosely on two books by Angela Kelly, The Queen’s senior dresser, advisor and confidante from 1994 to her death, albeit that Gigi is a conflation of her dressers from 1969, made into a working-class woman from Wigan with vaulting ambition and a blunt tongue for all but Her Majesty. She puts service and care first but  all while serving her own goals too.

credit:-Robert Day

Laura Main’s Gigi Gaunt, The Dresser in By Royal Appointment. Picture: Robert Day

Humour is not her bag, whereas Goodwin gives The Queen and especially her Milliner and Designer (based on Norman Hartnell) plenty of room for quips and observations. At the same time, the playwright counters those barbs and ripostes with emotional outpourings, whether by Asher’s Queen after her uncle, Lord Mountbatten’s death and the Windsor Castle fire, or Cottle’s unguarded Australian Milliner, when his partner dies in the grip of Aids.

Then add Robb’s guarded, repressed  Designer, recalling how his father favoured his chip-off-the-old-block older brother over him, a mere “shaving” despite his Military Cross and design prowess.

In a nutshell, By Royal Appointment is in part the tale of The Queen and a Buckingham Palace “stuffed with queens”, but Goodwin’s set-pieces feel mechanical in seeking a balance of humour and something deeper. The overall tone is light, and yet Main’s manipulative Dresser becomes embittered, except in the presence of The Queen.

Asher has the regal air, the manner and the stature, and a voice and look to carry off the changing of the years. In Goodwin’s dialogue, she lets us see behind the front, especially when expressing The Queen’s love for Prince Philip and how he made her heart throb, but around her the behaviour is mannered and restrained (save on occasion for Cottle’s Milliner).

Consequently the drama is as starched as a shirt collar, in keeping with the time-honoured British characteristic of chronic reserve that prevails.

By Royal Appointment is well dressed and well pressed by director Anthony Banks and designer Jonathan Fensom, but ultimately it says less than its clothes. Style over discontent.

Daniel Schumann, Lee Dean and The Arts Theatre, Cambridge, present By Royal Appointment, York Theatre Royal, until Saturday, 7.30pm plus 2pm Thursday and 2.30pm Saturday matinees; post-show discussion with cast members after Thursday’s 7.30pm show. Box office: 01904 623568 or yorktheatreroyal.co.uk.

Laura Main dresses for the occasion when stepping up for By Royal Appointment

Laura Main as The Dresser, Gigi Gaunt, dressed for The Queen’s funeral in Daisy Goodwin’s By Royal Appointment. Picture: Robert Day

CALL the Call The Midwife star! Laura Main has stepped in to replace the originally announced Samantha Womack in the tour of Daisy Goodwin’s debut play By Royal Appointment, playing York Theatre Royal this week.

“I had only two weeks of rehearsals – shorter than it would otherwise have been, and even then there were some things that were non-negotiable as I have to do panto at the Waterside Theatre in Aylesbury this Christmas” says Laura, who has played Shelagh Turner (formerly Sister Bernadette) in the BBC medical drama since 2012.

In the role of The Dresser, Laura is starring opposite Jane Asher as The Queen in Goodwin’s exploration of their relationship and how the pair created the public image of the world’s longest-reigning monarch.

The late Queen Elizabeth II was famous for her discretion, expressing what she really thought only through her wardrobe. In Goodwin’s play, The Queen is uninterested in fashion, at her happiest instead in a head scarf; her look is managed by her Designer (played by David Robb), her Milliner (Matthew Cottle) and most powerful of all, her Dresser (Main).

In Goodwin’s chronological play, the Dresser goes from advising the Queen on the colour of her lipsticks to the real power behind the throne, but the Dresser, like all royal favourites, is living on borrowed time.

“It’s such a wonderful play and such a wonderful subject, and so many things have slotted into place for me, like how I got a ticket to the exhibition of The Queen’s wardrobe at Buckingham Palace on a day off,” says Laura.

“This one ‘Return’ ticket appeared so I snapped it up, when they’re like gold dust, and so I had the chance to look at the dresses, the fabrics, the designs.

“On top of that, one of the things I’d been doing this year, after I’d bought the book for her,  was reading Gyles Brandreth’s book [Elizabeth: An Intimate Portrait) to my mum, who needs care and support these days.  It was like I’d been studying for this role and now it’s about getting the character [of the Dresser] right and doing her justice.”

Gooodman’s Dresser, Gigi Gaunt, is a composite of various dressers to The Queen from 1969 to 2022, most notably Angela Kelly, her personal assistant, adviser and dresser from 1994 until the monarch’s death, says Laura:  “We’re playing  all these different ages and all these significant times in The Queen’s life.”

Part of the joy of taking on The Dresser’s role was the chance to perform with Jane Asher. “It’s the first I’ve worked with Jane, and I would say one of my favourite moments was looking into Jane’s eyes for the first time as The Queen. It was pretty spine-tingling. Jane is so talented and nice and generous, and such fun. She’s an amazing person.”

Laura Main as The Dresser with Jane Asher as The Queen in By Royal Appointment. Picture: Robert Day

How did Laura “find” her character? “I hear what you say about thinking about who she is dressing and how extraordinary that is, but you have to find your own way in. The Dresser really loves The Queen, cares for her and she absolutely has that sense of responsibility of serving The Queen. They had this chemistry and bond,” she says.

“I know how it feels when you have to do something scary, where  you have to perform, and you have a make-up artist and wardrobe assistant making sure everything is OK, so I channel my friends from Call The Midwife into this role.”

Laura continues: “I know the Dresser is loosely based on Angela Kelly, and I’ve been listening to her audio-books, where she talks about those emotional moments, like before the State Opening of Parliament, where there’s just the two of them preparing in this small space;  the silence of those moments.”

Laura not only draws on Angela Kelly’s recollections, but she also has been working with costumer designer and fashion stylist Laura Parkes. “Again it’s a tiny window into that world, which in a way the Dresser has, as she’s not from that world [as a working-class woman from Wigan] but she has access to it,” she says.

“This woman is completely different to anyone I’ve played before, though there are elements that, as Laura, share. I feel really excited to be playing Gigi.”

Scottish actress Laura, who has mastered a Wigan accent for the role, says By Royal Appointment gives a complete picture of The Queen in a play that starts and ends with her funeral and looks back at significant moments in her reign.

“I feel that Daisy has created The Queen behind closed doors when there are tender moments, comical moments, real moments,” she says. “I suspect, having met Daisy, that she is maybe closer to the world of The Queen, having written about Queen Victoria too, but I feel that Gigi is singing off the page too.”

The dresses speak volumes in the play, designed for this production by Jonathan Fensom. “Having been to the exhibition at Buckingham Palace, it’s wonderful to see The Queen in so many iconic outfits. What style, spanning so much time, so many fashions, and she was really bold. I think she had such fun with what she wore,” says Laura. “Jonathan has made us all look fantastic in this heightened, elevated world.

“I have just one dress throughout, whereas The Queen is changing all the time. It’s a simple and stylish dress that can span all the times the play covers, which is really clever. The moment when Gigi was ‘here’ for me was when I first first wore the black hat, that dress, and coat for the funeral.”

Daniel Schumann, Lee Dean and The Arts Theatre, Cambridge, present By Royal Appointment, York Theatre Royal, until Saturday, 7.30pm plus 2pm Thursday and 2.30pm Saturday matinees; post-show discussion after Thursday’s 7.30pm show. Box office: 01904 623568 or yorktheatreroyal.co.uk. 

Laura Main as the Dresser in By Royal Appointment. Picture: Robert Day

Laura Main on saying Yes to playing The Dresser on tour either side of Christmas at short notice

“THERE were some things that were non-negotiable as I have to do panto at the Waterside Theatre in Aylesbury this Christmas, where I’m Fairy Snowfall in Sleeping Beauty,” says Laura.

“I did it in Sunderland last year and had so much fun that when they asked me again, with my mum needing care and support these days. it was my sisters who said, ‘you loved it, go and do it again’.

“With that care and support, my mum has been so much better, but it’s a wrench to leave her.

“I love theatre, I absolutely love it, but I do have family time too, which has been good, and then this opportunity to do By Royal Appointment came up. I know the director, Anthony Banks, after playing M’Lynn, Shelby’s mother, in Steel Magnolias, so right at this moment in time, being offered a huge, huge tour for a long time…

“…you never know what will be right right for you personally and creatively, but I did really want to do some more theatre as I love all the magic of storytelling, the connection with the audience and the chance to play a new character.

“There’s a week off before the panto starts and a week off afterwards, and then we start again in Aberdeen, which is where I’m from and where my mum lives. I thought, when am I going to get the time to do both, acting and looking after my mum, and it felt like Anthony was giving me the chance to do both.

“These are less than perfect circumstances, but we can make it work. I’ve found freedom in doing this role because, in a way, there’s less to prove as you’re stepping in and helping out.”

Dressed for multiple occasions, Jane Asher tackles regal role as The Queen in By Royal Appointment at York Theatre Royal

Jane Asher as The Queen and Laura Main as The Dresser in Daisy Goodwin’s play The Dresser, on tour at York Theatre Royal next week. Picture: Robert Day

DAISY Goodwin wrote ITV’s historical drama series Victoria. Now, her debut play, 2025’s By Royal Appointment, is to tour to York Theatre Royal next week in a co-production presented by Daniel Schumann, Lee Dean and The Arts Theatre, Cambridge.

Directed by Anthony Banks and designed by Jonathan Fensom, the play stars Jane Asher as The Queen and Laura Main as The Dresser, replacing the originally announced Samantha Womack.

By Royal Appointment explores their relationship and how the pair created the public image of the world’s longest-reigning monarch, Queen Elizabeth II, who was famous for her discretion, never saying anything in public that could ruffle the lightest of feathers. However, Her Majesty had one way of expressing what she really thought – through her wardrobe. 

Goodwin’s humorous, poignant and celebratory play considers the kind of power that only a Queen can wield, charming the world through coats and admonishing her family through a carefully chosen hat.

Yet Goodwin depicts The Queen as uninterested in fashion, her look being managed by her Designer (played by David Robb), her Milliner (Matthew Cottle’s role) and most powerful of all, her Dresser (Main).

In By Royal Appointment, the Dresser is a working-class girl who goes from advising The Queen on the colour of her lipsticks to the real power behind the throne. However, the Dresser, like all royal favourites, is living on borrowed time.

Taking the regal role in Goodwin’s  behind-the-scenes peek into the world of our most popular monarch and the image she presented to the world is “acting royalty” Jane Asher, the queen of cake bakers to boot.

“I was asked if I would like to do the role,” says Jane, now 80. “I was sent the play – I didn’t know it existed. It’s pretty much new but was first done in a different version last year. I read it and thought it was a somewhat terrifying prospect, but I knew the producer, Lee Dean, who asked me to do it before there was a director attached.

“By chance, a few weeks previously, Anthony had sent me a lovely message via my agent after seeing me in a rehearsed reading at the Orange Tree [Richmond, London]. I knew of him and his work, and when Lee suggested him to me I jumped at it.”

By Royal Appointment is based loosely on the books by The Queen’s senior dresser, Angela Kelly: Dressing The Queen (2012) and The Other Side Of The Coin: The Queen, The Dresser And The Wardrobe, (2019)].

“She more or less became her carer towards the end and had been given permission by The Queen to write the books,” says Jane.

“So the role was irresistible for me: challenging, terrifying but wonderful too. People do really seem to be enjoying it: people of my age group and younger too, really love it, remembering some of The Queen’s clothes that got into your psyche. To see those clothes being brought to life again is remarkable, but of course it’s about much more than that.”

By Royal Appointment is being well received on tour. “I’ve done a great many new plays and I always enjoy it, partly because the writer is usually still alive – and so ‘straight from the horse’s mouth’ is still available,” says Jane.

Jane Asher as The Queen, surrounded by regal clothing in By Royal Appointment. Picture: Robert Day

“You never know how the audience will take it, whether they will laugh or go quiet, but they’re enjoying this play, where with some jokes you get the most from them if you know the history. Overall it’s one of those plays that’s both funny and sad.”

By Royal Appointment is a slice of theatre vérité. “All the characters are taken from reality, so what you have – almost a first – is the chance to go behind the scenes, getting an insight backstage,” says Jane, who drew mostly on the script for her characterisation.

“I didn’t do specific research beyond checking certain dramatic moments in The Queen’s life, such as Lord Mountbatten’s boat being  blown up by IRA bombers, happier times too, and her children’s marriages.

“I’ve gone mainly with Daisy’s view because she’s such a good writer about the Royals. It’s terrifying that so many other actors have played The Queen, and I’ve not ignored them, because they’re deeply ingrained, but I can only do Jane Asher’s version, which will never be The Queen, but audiences will accept this version.”

Did Jane ever encounter The Queen? “Yes, like many actors, I’ve been lucky enough to meet her a few times, like at a do at Buckingham Palace, and when my husband [illustrator and political cartoonist Gerald Scarfe] received the CBE [in October 2008], The Queen did the ceremony and I was there that day.”

Here is a statistic to ponder: “People dream about The Queen more than any other figurehead, which is relatively common,” says Jane. “It may be rather banal to say, but she did reign for an incredibly long time.

“She was so incredibly good at her job, fantastic in that way of being tactful and resolute that no-one should know her political views, and she did such wonderful things in speaking through her ‘clothes’.

“She just loved being in her head scarf and knitted skirt in the Highlands, because I can imagine that if you have to dress up in grand, uncomfortable clothes, you would long to get back into casual wear!”

Central to Jane’s role in By Royal Appointment is the clothing. “I love clothes, so of course it’s a lovely part of the job of acting to wear completely different clothes, but in a play like this, with eight or nine changes, it can get a bit tiring. I’d love to go back to playing a cavewoman!”

Jane wrote about clothing in Jane Asher’s Costume Book: Over 100 Costumes for Children and Adults and How to Make Them. “I thoroughly approve of things like Vinted,” she says. “I’ve always appreciated beautiful clothes that have been kept. I like being dressed in period clothes or ‘vintage’ clothes as they’re now called – but second-hand as I called them.”

Daniel Schumann, Lee Dean and The Arts Theatre, Cambridge, present By Royal Appointment, York Theatre Royal, November 10 to 14, 7.30pm plus 2pm Wednesday & Thursday and 2.30pm Saturday matinees; post-show discussion with cast members after Thursday’s 7.30pm show. Age guidance: 14 plus. Box office: 01904 623568 or yorktheatreroyal.co.uk.

One last question for Jane Asher, cookery book writer

What do you consider to be the Queen of cakes?

“That’s so tricky: as with most food, so much depends on one’s mood! I don’t have a particularly sweet tooth so although I love making beautiful iced cakes for special occasions, if I was making one for myself to have a slice with a cup of tea I’d choose something like the old-fashioned Madeira – simple but delicious…”

Jane Asher: Actress, businesswoman and author

Jane Asher: back story

Stage credits include: Twelfth Night, The Circle (Orange Tree Theatre); A Song At Twilight, Moon Tiger (Theatre Royal Bath); An American In Paris (Dominion Theatre); Great Expectations (West Yorkshire Playhouse); The Gathered Leaves (Park Theatre); Pride And Prejudice (Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre); Charley’s Aunt (Menier Chocolate Factory); The Importance Of Being Earnest, Farewell To The Theatre, Bedroom Farce (Rose Theatre Kingston), The Reluctant Debutant (Yvonne Arnaud Theatre).

Before The Party (Queen’s Theatre); Blythe Spirit, Henceforward, House/Garden (Vaudeville Theatre); Festen (Almeida Theatre), Look Back In Anger (Royal Court Theatre, Criterion Theatre); Making It Better (Hampstead Theatre, Criterion Theatre); Measure For Measure, Romeo and Juliet, The Happiest Days Of Your Life… (Bristol Old Vic, US tour); Old Flames (Bristol Old Vic).

Peter Pan (Shaftesbury Theatre); Strawberry Fields, The School For Scandal, To Those Born Later (National Theatre); The Philanthropist (Royal Court Theatre, Mayfair Theatre, Broadway); The Shallow End, The Worlds Biggest Diamond, Treats (Royal Court Theatre) and Things We Do For Love (Gielgud Theatre).

Her film credits include: A Family Affair;  Splinter; Burn Burn Burn; I Give It A Year; Alfie; Closing Numbers; Death At A Funeral; Deep End; Dream Child; Henry VIII And His Six Wives; Paris By Night and Runners.

For television: Crossing Lines; Pompidou; Eve, Stella; The Old Guys; Poirot: 3 Act Tragedy; The Palace; A For Andromeda; Crossroads; Miss Marple; The Mistress; Brideshead Revisited and The Mill On The Floss.

Books: Three novels,The Longing, The Question, and Losing It.

Lifestyle, costuming and cake-decorating books: Jane Asher’s Fancy Dress; Jane Asher’s Quicky Party Cakes; Jane Asher’s Tricks Of The Trade; Jane Asher’s Costume Book; Jane Asher’s Children’s Parties; Jane Asher’s Eat For Treats; The Complete Christmas Book; Jane Asher’s Calendar Of Cakes; Jane Asher’s Complete Book Of Cake Decorating Ideas; The Best Of Good Living With Jane Asher; Good Living At Christmas With Jane Asher; Cakes For Fun; Beautiful Baking and Jane Asher’s Easy Celebration Cakes.

Children’s books: Moppy Is Angry; Moppy Is Calm; Moppy Is Happy; Moppy Is Sad and Rhymes For All Seasons.

Businesswoman:Owns a company that makes party cakes and sugar crafts for special occasions.

Did you know? Jane is a shareholder in the satirical magazine Private Eye.

Did you know too? Jane has served as the president of the National Autistic Society since 1997.

REVIEW: Handbagged, Stephen Joseph Theatre, Scarborough, until August 29 *****

No common ground: Pandora Clifford’s Mags and Liz Garland’s Liz in Handbagged at the SJT. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

THIRTY six years since her resignation and 13 since she died at the Ritz Hotel, Margaret Thatcher still drew boos and derision from the SJT audience – in a town that only turned red from decades of Tory MPs in 2024.

There was a smattering of cheers too, drawing more boos from the derisive naysayers for a Westminster titan that remains as divisive as ever in an age of increasingly short-lived minnows in Downing Street.

Moira Buffini’s 2013 play – so full of wit, brio and intelligence – is neither biased nor one-sided in its depiction of Mrs T, instead letting her speak, vehemently, vigorously, and even vituperatively, for herself over her 11 years as the UK’s first female  Prime Minister. She stands and – seemingly in many eyes and ears on press night – falls by her words.

Words that were fired off in the direction of the other dominant female presence of the British 20th century, Queen Elizabeth II, in their weekly meetings at Buckingham Palace and beyond.

Director Hannah Tyrrell-Pinder in the rehearsal room with Handbagged cast member Simon Darwen. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

Revived by the Stephen Joseph Theatre under the directorship of Hannah Tyrrell-Pinder (whose father, Andrew Pinder, received a CBE for his services to Tony Blair’s Labour government), Handbagged is built on the classic political structure of conflict where people talk but don’t engage in conversation.

Born within six months of each other but poles and circumstances apart, albeit that both had to face a patriarchal world, the PM and HM The Queen serve as a double act, or, to be precise, a double double act, on account of Buffini doubling the combat between  a younger Mags (Pandora Clifford) and Liz (Liz Garland), from the weekly audiences, and an older T (Alexandra Mathie, wig too dark) and Q (Meriel Scholfield).

Observing their younger selves, they each say equally quizzically, “I never said that”, as if they have become unreliable witnesses to their earlier sentiments and assertions.

That said, everything Buffini writes of their awkward conflabs behind closed doors can only be conjecture to complement words from public utterances and Mrs Thatcher’s Downing Street Years memoirs.

Alexandra Mathie’s T: Doubling down on her political philosophies in old age in Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

Grim reading: Pandora Clifford’s Mags flicking through the Sunday paper headlines in Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

Yet she writes with such cultural savvy, comedic conviction, assiduous detail, such a grasp of her satirical subject, that she brings to mind the mischief-making of  political heavyweights The Thick Of It , House Of Cards or Yes, Prime Minister. It feels all the more truthful for the assured voice of Buffini.

A third double act is at play: our convivial hosts Actor One (Deven Modha) and Actor 2 (Simon Darwen), who spar over who should play Labour Leader Neil “Kinnockio” Kinnock, while allocating themselves such support acts as Denis Thatcher, Prince Philip (only one irascible line), Gerry Adams, Geoffrey Howe, Ronald Reagan, Rupert Murdoch and Michael Heseltine (all Darwen), and Kenneth Kaunda, Nancy Reagan, Michael Shea, Kenneth Clarke, a Palace footman and protestor (all Modha, while refusing to play Enoch Powell).

Serving as Greek chorus too, both challenge Mrs Thatcher’s tendency to skip over her most controversial policies, only to be forced to confront them anew. Throughout their mimicry of accent and mannerism is spot on.

Multi-rolling Actor I (Deven Modha), left, and Actor 2 (Simon Darwen) playing First Lady Nancy Reagan and President Ronald Reagan in Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

Deven Modha’s No Poll Tax protestor in Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

On the surface, you could be inclined to decide that everyone loves the Queen (especially in Garland and Scholfield’s superb caricatures), whereas Maggie, whether younger or older, remains the humourless villainess of the piece in Clifford and Mathie’s characterisation.  Buffini’s writing is far too bright for that, however, all while making Mrs T funny on occasion through jokes at her expense when breaking through that humour dead zone.

Buffin seeks the humanity in both women. Margaret Thatcher is given every chance to state,  re-state and  double down on political philosophies, and we see her change, as her voice does, ironically adopting “we” when she becomes more “I” and isolated as she loses her allies. Always and forever, her favourite word is No. No. No, until no more.

The Queen’s Christmas Day addresses are the cornerstone of her portrayal: one of compassion, a call for kindness, and in essence Socialist principles from the richest woman in the land. Through the years, PM and HM talk but never bond, for all that time and tea consumption together, never finding common ground.

Out of step? Liz Garland’s Liz dancing with Simon Darwen’s Denis Thatcher and Pandora Clifford’s Mags doing likewise with Deven Modha’s Kenneth Kaunda in Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

All six performances are top notch, matched by Pinder’s astute direction, using the Round as a battlefield, where she keeps moving the combatants to emphasise the shifting tectonic plates of the relationship.

Katie Scott’s design is circular too, giving the sense of a merry-go-round thanks in part to Aiden Crawford’s movement direction. A museum shelf of named props and costumes on the stage rim works wonderfully well too for speed of character changes before your very eyes.

As the years tick by since the passing of both protagonists, Handbagged becomes an ever better play, one where Buffini’s skill in weaving her own mischievous political commentary into her modern-day comedy of manners is delivered with witheringly witty  aplomb. Bag a ticket pronto.

Handbagged, Stephen Joseph Theatre, Scarborough, until August 29. Box office: 01723 370541 or sjt.uk.com.

Pandora Clifford’s Mags, Liz Garland’s Liz, Meriel Scholfield’s Q and Alexandra Mathie’s T expressing differing opinions in Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

Everything stops for tea: Meriel Scholfied’s Q raises a cup and humorous quips aplenty in Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

When The Queen met Mrs Thatcher each week for 11 years, what was said? Let Handbagged imagine the power play at SJT

Hangbagged director Hannah Tyrrell-Pinder working with cast member Simon Darwen. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

THEY met once a week for 11 years. One believed there was no such thing as society. The other committed her life to serving it.

On stage at the Stephen Joseph Theatre, Scarborough, from tonight until August 29, Moira Buffini’s comedy Handbagged imagines what happened behind closed palace doors when two of the world’s most powerful women, Queen Elizabeth II and Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, clashed.

Spanning 1979 to 1990, this Olivier Award-winning 2014 play asks if HM The Queen and her PM, the Iron Lady, ever found common ground or did their stiff upper lips reign supreme?

The SJT revival is in the hands of director Hannah Tyrrell-Pinder, whose later father, Andrew Pinder, served as the UK’s e-Envoy from 2000 to 2004 under Prime Minister Tony Blair,  receiving his CBE from The Queen in 2004.

“He was going to turn it down because of his working-class Yorkshire  roots [he was born in Sheffield] and being a dyed-in-the-wool Labour voter – we grew up never watching The Queen’s Christmas message on TV – but everyone else talked him into it because I wanted to go to Buckingham Palace!” recalls Hannah.

“We just got to stand at the back while Dad got his honour from The Queen, with a proper handshake and a bow, but I do remember us being driven through the palace gates, having our photos taken like we were important.”

Hannah has now come into rather closer contact with The Queen, at least theatrically, in being at the helm of Handbagged, with its two versions of Elizabeth II, Meriel Scholfield’s Q, the older monarch, and Liz Garland’s Liz,  her younger self, playing opposite Alexandra Mathie’s T and Pandora Clifford’s Mags.

“I’m absolutely thrilled to be directingHandbagged at the SJT this summer, working with this brilliant company of actors to bring to life some of the most prominent figures from recent history,” says Hannah.

Pandora Clifford, left, and Alexandra Mathie in the SJT rehearsal room. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

“Presenting Handbagged in the Round is so exciting, engaging in an immediate dialogue with our audience, and bringing them face to face with two of the most powerful women of the 20th century.”

Hannah knew SJT artistic director Paul Robinson in his time in the same post at Theatre503, when she was first starting out as Box Of Tricks’ joint artistic director and co-founder, and had worked with Amy Fisher, now the SJT’s head of producing, at Box Of Tricks (where Amy is a board member).

After talking to Paul about freelance work, he came back with the suggestion of Hannah directing Handbagged in the summer season and liked her ideas on how to stage it. Amy was a useful source too on how to make a play speak to the SJT audience, one steeped in the comedies of Sir Alan Ayckbourn since 1959.

“They’re a lovely audience, where they’re so invested in having a good time and care so much about their theatre and want to have pride in it,” says Hannah.

Ayckbourn’s 92nd play, The Trial Of Romeo Oscar, a futuristic drama exploring what it means to be human in 2194, will open six days after Handbagged concludes its look-back at the recent past.

“I’m surprised that we’ve not seen more versions of Margaret Thatcher on stage because she’s such a fascinating character,  and even though The Queen has left us too, we are still caught up in how she represented us,” says Hannah. “Margaret Thatcher had a similar impact on our psyche: for some people, she was the utmost villain; for others, she was a real inspiration.”

Analysing Handbagged’s theatrical style, Hannah says: “The show is very interesting because it is so meta-theatrical and theatrically literate, dipping into the notion of storytelling and the art of telling the truth. They [The Queens and PM] may say ‘I’m not  a fan of theatre’, but they both enjoyed theatre, they both loved music and went to musical theatre, and they understood the value of art, so there’s a lot to learn about them that way.

“I don’t think they would have been unhappy about being the subject of a play when language was so important to both of them, given how much they had to communicate with words, and with the gaps in between; the nuances that go with that, when there’s so much in between the lines.”

Liz Garland, left, and Meriel Scholfield in rehearsal for the Stephen Joseph Theatre production of Handbagged. Picture: Tony Bartholomew

In the distinction between politician and monarch, Mrs T could be frank, where The Queen could not. “You can’t fault Margaret Thatcher for her force of vision, when she could have been more collaborative. You don’t have that force now, when politicians try to prevaricate about a subject, where you can’t be certain about what they think,” says Hannah.

“For The Queen, it was a hard role because she repressed so much and had to be in control of what she said.”

Margaret Thatcher’s 1993 book, The Downing Street Years, all 900-plus pages of it, was invaluable to constructing her character in Handbagged. “Whereas The Queen is a much trickier proposition, where we want to know what she was like behind her public appearances, what she was like behind closed doors, because people were so loyal to her, so it’s difficult to get a sense of that voice,” says Hannah,

“But there’s something enjoyable about knowing you can never have the ‘true’ voice but you can bring playfulness and irreverence to it. As a piece of theatre, Handbagged enters a contract with the audience where we suspend disbelief and you’re given licence to say it’s as much about interpretation as it is about what you’re seeing, and with these two women that’s even more enjoyable.”

Hannah grew up in a “very anti-Thatcher household, and not fans of the Royal Family either”, but in working on Handbagged, she has developed “respect for just how much Margaret Thatcher had to deal with the patriarchy – respect for both of them, in  fact.”

“It was so much more difficult for them than if they had been men, particularly for Margaret Thatcher, living in a strict religious community, going to church four times on Sundays, as the daughter of a Methodist lay preacher,” she says.

“She had this sharp, sparky brain that she couldn’t use at first, but she kept fighting to use it, and you have to have respect for that, just as I developed an admiration for Denis Thatcher, how they really supported each other in a loving relationship and were an example of a loving marriage that worked. That’s been a realisation for me.”

Handbagged runs at Stephen Joseph Theatre, Scarborough, tonight until August 29. Box office: 01723 370541 or sjt.uk.com.

Secret Link