REVIEW: Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers, Grand Opera House, York, until Sat *****

Vivienne Carlyle’s Mrs Johnstone and Sean Jones’s Mickey in Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers, on tour at the Grand Opera House, York. Picture: Jack Merriman

WILLY Russell’s tragi-comic Liverpool musical is visiting York for a remarkable tenth time since 1996. No show can rival that record, not even fellow regulars The Rocky Horror Show or Buddy: The Buddy Holly Story.

Ticket demand is as high as ever: Monday’s press night was packed to the gills, opening a week’s run that accommodates three rather than the routine two matinees (Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday).

Should you somehow still be a Blood Brothers virgin, make sure to initiate yourself in Russell’s modern-day Jacobean tragedy on its first York outing since 2022, when your reviewer considered the combination of Niki Evans’s Mrs Johnstone, Sean Jones’s Mickey, in his “last ever tour”, Joel Benedict’s Eddie, Carly Burns’s Linda and Robbie Scotcher’s Narrator to be “better than ever”.

The 2025 leads are more than a match, especially Scottish actress Vivienne Carlyle’s Mrs Johnston, with a singing voice to rival Annie Lennox, and Sean Keany’s tall, gaunt grim reaper of an Irish-accented Narrator. Sean Jones, meanwhile, has still not left the building – was he taking the Mickey when he said 2022‘s tour would be the final curtain after 23 years on and off in Blood Brothers’ baggy green jumper and short trousers?! – but why would he leave a role he has made his own?  

At 54, Jones continues to pour blood, sweat and tears into his combustible combination of bouncy comic timing [as seen each winter in his daft lad role in the Florian Pavilion, New Brighton panto too] and heartrending pathos on Mickey’s doomed path from skip to slouch to slump, from cheeky, boundlessly energetic child to lovelorn, tongue-tied teen, to crushed, enervated adult, broken on the wheel of anti-depressants and redundancy.

Impresario and producer Bill Kenwright – who had asked Jones to return to the role in 2022 – has passed away since that tour but the 2025 production still carries his stamp, credited as co-director with Bob Tomson, the team that brought Russell’s  Blood Brothers to its emotional heights with gold standard production values to boot.

Vivienne Carlyle first worked with Kenwright and Tomson in 2006, playing Mrs Lyons and understudying Mrs J at the Phoenix Theatre in London, later appearing as Mrs Lyons at the Grand Opera House on tour in 2008, and she now returns to Mrs J after a 12-year gap, bringing scabrous Scouse humour, love, fierce passion, desperate resilience and guilty pain to the secret-burdened Catholic mother at the heart of Russell’s1983 cautionary tale of twin brothers separated at birth and cursed by a fateful superstition that if either should discover the other’s existence, they will die instantly.

Already struggling with too many children on an impoverished Liverpool estate and deserted by her wastrel husband, Mrs J’s budget on the never-never means she can only “afford” one child more, not two, and so cleaner Mrs J rashly enters a pact with her employer, a travelling salesman’s barren wife, Mrs Lyons (Sarah Jane Buckley), to give her the choice of the twins.

Whereupon, seen from the age of seven upwards, Jones’s scally urchin Mickey and Joe Sleight’s initially naïve, then scholarly Eddie are divided by the class divide that Russell lambasts, but their paths are destined to keep crossing, as fate plays its hand as much as social circumstance, turning their “blood brother” bond in adolescent rites of passage to adult separation.

Ever present in the shadows on Andy Walmsley’s set of house frontages, a mezzanine level and backdrops of Liverpool Liver Building skyscraper and the verdant countryside is Keany’s Narrator, a Faustian debt collector as dark as his suit and tie, overseeing innocent child’s play making way for crime and tragic final resolution, guns turning from toys to real.

From Vivienne Carlyle’s renditions of Tell Me It’s Not True, Marilyn Monroe and Easy Terms to Gemma Brodrick’s lovely performance as teen crush Linda, caught between Mickey and Eddie, to Nick Richings’ lighting and Matt Malone’s band, the 2025 tour of Blood Brothers shines with high quality in the transition from comedy to tragedy, the two faces of theatre writ large in this peerless, hard-hitting, unsentimental yet emotionally shattering musical.

Bill Kenwright Ltd presents Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers, Grand Opera House, York, until Saturday, 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Thursday and Saturday matinees. Box office: atgtickets.com/York. Age recommendation: 12 plus.

Vivienne Carlyle delights in return to Grand Opera House as Blood Brothers makes record tenth York visit from Tuesday

Vivienne Carlyle’s Mrs Johnstone in Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers, on tour at Grand Opera House, York, from next Tuesday

THE Grand Opera House in York holds special memories for Scottish actress Vivienne Carlyle ahead of her appearance there as Mrs Johnstone in Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers.

“I’m so delighted to be going back to York as I made my debut there as the Narrator in Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat in 1999 with Richard Swerrun – who’s sadly since passed away – as Joseph,” she recalls,

“I remember messing up the brothers’ names, saying ‘Zebedee’ instead of ‘Zebulun’, and do you know why? It’s because one of the ‘brothers’ said to me just before going on, ‘make sure you don’t say ‘Zebedee’…and of course I then said it! Oh, the humiliation!”

Vivienne went on to play adoptive mother Mrs Lyons, the rich, barren businessman’s wife up the hill for whom Mrs Johnstone cleans, in Blood Brothers on tour at the York theatre in 2008 and now takes top billing as Russell’s emotionally turbulent musical makes its tenth visit – yes, tenth – from April 1 .

“I’m originally from Glasgow, so I grew up at the King’s Theatre, where you couldn’t keep me off the stage from being a wee tot. I remember going to see Blood Brothers when I was eight years old with my mum and dad, sitting there, riveted, in silence,” says Vivienne, who “had the lovely honour of going back there in October to play Mrs Johnstone”.

Blood Brothers carries a minimum age recommendation of 12, but Vivienne was mesmerised by the musical all of four years younger. “Because you have adults playing kids in it, that captures your imagination,” she says.

Vivienne Carlyle’s Mrs Johnstone and Seán Keany’s Narrator in Blood Brothers. Picture: Jack Merriman

Vivienne saw the show a couple more times before joining the London cast in 2006, playing Mrs Lyons at the Phoenix and understudying Mrs Johnstone too. “Every so often, I would play Mrs Johnstone on tour,” she says.

“One time, when Linda Nolan’s husband Brian had passed away, I was in Joseph at the time and they asked me if I could do a Saturday matinee of Blood Brothers, in Linda’s place,  in Dunstable and then put me in a taxi back to High Wycombe for the evening performance as the Narrator in Joseph, which I played in the West End as well.”

Blood Brothers, a musical as powerful in impact as a Greek tragedy or an  opera, tells the heartrending tale of twins separated at birth, who grow up on the opposite sides of the tracks in Liverpool, only to meet again with tragic consequences. 

At its heart is Mrs Johnstone, a young mother deserted by her wastrel husband. Left to her own devices to provide for seven hungry children, she takes a job as a housekeeper to make ends meet, but discovers she is pregnant yet again, this time with twins. In a moment of weakness and desperation, she enters a secret pact with her employer, Mrs Lyons, with shattering consequences.

Note Mrs J is described as a ‘young mother’, and yet she has been played by actresses of myriad ages, Lyn Paul, for example, still playing her into her 70s. “The script direction says Mrs J ‘is 30 but looks 50,” says Vivienne, who gives her own age as “in the 40 to 50 bracket”. “It works, whatever age, because she starts the story at the end, in the boys’ adult years.

“I started playing her in my 30s, considered very young for the role, and after playing her for nine months just before it closed in the West End in 2012, I’m now coming back to it from a 12-year gap, after all the curve balls that life throws at you.”

“It always has to be as raw and authentic as possible to make it believable,” says Vivienne Carlyle. “You feel those emotions every time you do it, and that’s a testimony to Willy Russell’s writing.” Picture: Jack Merriman

Vivienne believes she benefited from playing Mrs Lyons first. “Very much so. Even from the perspective of working with all the other great Mrs Johnstones, seeing their creative processes,” she says.

“It gives you the perspective of both these women, both trying to do the best they can in their different ways. I’ve had so many mothers come up to me to say that when Mrs Johnstone gives her child Mickey away to Mrs Lyons, they can feel their heart turn.”

Blood Brothers remains as potent as ever, as much a fixture on the GCSE English Literature syllabus as on the theatre calendar. “We have a really wonderful director in Bob Tomson, who instills in us that it always has to be as raw and authentic as possible to make it believable. You feel those emotions every time you do it, or every time you see it, and that’s a testimony to Willy’s writing.

“The songs are iconic too, Tell Me It’s Not , Easy Terms, and it amazes me still when young people come to the stage door to tell me how much they love the show, buying into the 1950s to 1990s story; the culture and the politics; whether it’s fate or not fate. But no matter what age you are, you will connect with it.”

On tour since January, Vivienne is into the final three weeks of the spring itinerary. “We don’t yet know the casting for the rest of the year but of course I’d like to continue in it,” she concludes.

By her side is Blood Brothers mainstay Sean Jones, still playing Mrs Johnstone’s son Mickey from the age of seven, despite the 2022 itinerary being billed as his farewell tour after more than two decades, with all the accompanying interviews that went with that announcement.

Vivienne Carlyle’s Mrs Johnstone with Sean Jones’s Mickey, the “gift of a role” he continues to play at 54. Picture: Jack Merriman

“Sean is a remarkable actor,” says Vivienne. “When he said he was stopping, he meant it, but when you’re asked to come back ‘for a little while’, it can end up that you stay in!

“We first worked together when I did the tour as Mrs Lyons, so we’re old pals. He thinks of Mickey as a gift of a role, and so is Mrs J, who’s an extraordinary woman. Thing after thing happens to her: her husband leaves her; she finds she’s pregnant, with seven children already, but she never remains defeated.

“She always and tries to be strong and that’s what people do throughout the world, doing the best they can. That’s what people connect with in this play: everyday people with everyday problems.”

Playing Mrs Johnstone is emotionally and physically draining. “My duty is to keep fit,” says Vivienne. “I don’t drink when I’m working; I rest my voice: I eat well; I exercise; I do the bare minimum each day till I go on stage. It’s not a hardship. I love doing it; it’s what I do to bring Mrs J to the heights I want to.

“There’s a lot of stamina needed, but muscle memory kicks and it gets easier, the more you play it.”

Bill Kenwright Ltd presents Blood Brothers, Grand Opera House, York, April 1 to 5, 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday matinees. Box office: atgtickets.com/York. Age recommendation: 12 plus.

Vivienne Carlyle: the back story

Vivienne Carlyle: First appeared at Grand Opera House, York, in 1999 as the Narrator in Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat

SCOTTISH Scottish actor, singer and voiceover artist, who works in the UK and internationally.

Theatre credits include: Mrs Lyons and Mrs Johnstone in Blood Brothers (Phoenix Theatre, London and UK Tour); Songbird in Cirque du Soleil’s Saltimbanco (South American tour); Narrator in Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat (West End debut at New London Theatre and on tour); The Drowsy Chaperone (Novello Theatre, Original London Cast); Grizabella in Cats (Royal Caribbean); Usha in Lightseeker (Resort World Theatre, Singapore); Mrs Walker in The Who’s Tommy (UK tour); Queen Cackle in Geronimo Stilton Live On Stage (Singapore, Hong Kong); Mother Gothel in Tangled The Musical and Lady Tremaine in Twice Charmed (Broadway guest artist, Disney Cruise Line); Songs For
Everafter, one-woman show of Disney classics (also co-writer, Disney
Cruise Line).

TV credits include: Country singer Mindy McCready in Autopsy: The Last Hours Of Mindy
McCready (ITV); Narrator in Joseph And The Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat for Blue Peter (BBC).

Recording credits include: ALBA, 1719, Sands Of Time and Showtime for
Scottish Opera, Shehallion and Lightseeker (Original Cast Recording).

Performed backing vocals for Barry Manilow, Michael Bolton and Dina Carroll.

More Things To Do in York and beyond when night-time incidents spark curiosity. Hutch’s List No. 13, from The York Press

Kiki Dee & Carmelo Ruggeri: Heading to All Saints Church, Pocklington on The Long Ride Home tour

FOUR nights of Greg Davies and tenth visit of Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers are the headline acts in Charles Hutchinson’s bill for cultural satisfaction.

Acoustic duo of the week: Kiki Dee & Carmelo Luggeri, All Saints Church, Pocklington, tonight, 7.30pm

JOIN Bradford-born singer Kiki Dee and guitarist Carmelo Luggeri for an acoustic journey through their songs and stories, taking in songs from 2022 album The Long Ride Home, Kate Bush and Frank Sinatra covers and hits from Kiki’s 55 years and more in the music business, Don’t Go Breaking My Heart, Star, I Got The Music In Me, Loving & Free and Amoureuse. Box office: kikiandcarmelo.com.

Brighouse & Rastrick Band: A blast of brass on Sunday afternoon at Pocklington Arts Centre

Brass concert of the week: Brighouse & Rastrick Band, Pocklington Arts Centre, tomorrow, 2pm

FOREVER associated with 1977 number two hit and “unofficial encore” The Floral Dance, West Yorkshire’s Brighouse & Rastrick Band presents a concert suitable for casual listener and connoisseur alike.

The majority of premier band championships have been held by ‘Briggus’, most recently becoming the 2022 British Open and Brass in Concert champions. ‘Briggus’ are noted too for collaborations outside the brass band tradition, from the late Terry Wogan to Kate Rusby, classical actor Simon Callow to The Unthanks at York Minster in 2012. Box office: 01759 301547 or pocklingtonartscentre.co.uk.

Tom Holland: Hailing Caesars at Grand Opera House, York

History lesson of the week: Tom Holland, The Lives Of The Caesars, Grand Opera House, York, Sunday, 7.30pm

THE Rest Is History podcaster and storyteller Tom Holland journeys back to the Roman empire to “get up close and personal” with Caesar, Augustus, Caligula and Nero as he spotlights the lives of the first 12 Roman emperors in conversation with Martha Kearney.

In this supreme arena, emperors had no choice but to fight, to thrill, to dazzle, as highlighted in Holland’s new Penguin Classics translation of Suetonius’s Lives Of The Twelve Caesars. Expect revelations of the emperors’ shortfalls, sex scandals, tastes, foibles and eccentricities. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.

Vivienne Carlyle’s Mrs Johnstone and Sean Jones’s Mickey in Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers, on tour at Grand Opera House, York. Picture: Jack Merriman

Musical of the week: Blood Brothers, Grand Opera House, York, April 1 to 5, 7.30pm plus 2.30pm Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday matinees

WILLY Russell’s Liverpool musical makes its tenth visit to the Grand Opera House, and despite Sean Jones’s appearance in the 2022 tour being billed as his “last ever” after 23 years on and off as Mrs Johnstone’s son Mickey, here he is once more, still  “running around as a seven-year-old in a baggy green jumper and short trousers” at 54.

Scottish actress Vivienne Carlyle, who played Mrs Lyons on her previous Blood Brothers visit to York, takes the role of Mrs J in Russell’s moving tale of twins separated at birth, who grow up on the opposite sides of the tracks, only to meet again with tragic consequences. Box office: atgtickets.com/york.

Curiouser and curiouser: Pick Me Up Theatre in The Curious Incident Of The Dog In The Night-Time at Theatre@41, Monkgate, York

Play of the week: Pick Me Up Theatre in The Curious Incident Of The Dog In The Night-Time, Theatre@41, Monkgate, York, April 1 to 5,7.30pm plus 2.30pm Wednesday, Thursday and Saturday

ANDREW Isherwood directs York company Pick Me Up Theatre in Simon Stephens’s stage adaptation of Mark Haddon’s story of Christopher Boone (Jonathan Wells), a 15-year-old boy with an extraordinary brain Exceptionally gifted at Maths, he finds everyday life and interaction with other people very confusing.

Christopher has never ventured alone beyond the end of his road, hates being touched and deeply distrusts strangers, but everything changes when he falls under suspicion for killing his neighbour’s dog, propelling him on a journey of self-discovery that upturns his world. Box office: tickets.41monkgate.co.uk.

Greg Davies: Milking it in his Full Fat Legend stand-up show

Comedy gigs of the week: Greg Davies: Full Fat Legend, York Barbican, April 2 to 5,

TOWERING comedian Greg Davies plays York Barbican for a full-fat four nights on his Full Fat Legend Tour, his first on British soil for seven years.

The 6ft 8 inch star of Taskmaster, The Inbetweeners, The Cleaner, Never Mind The Buzzcocks, Man Down and Cuckoo is undertaking his biggest stand-up tour to date. He last played York Barbican on November 1 and 2 2017 on his You Magnificent Beast tour, his first travels for four years. Tickets update: Sold out; for returns only, go to yorkbarbican.co.uk. Davies’s Hull Connexin Live shows on June 3 and 4 and at Leeds First Direct Arena on June 20 are sold out too.

Daniel Wilmot’s Count Dracula in Baron Productions’ Dracula at St Mary’s Church, Bishophill Junior, York

High stakes of the week: Baron Productions in Dracula, St Mary’s Church, Bishophill Junior, York, April 3 to 5, 7.30pm

FOUNDER and director Daniel Wilmot makes it Count when starring as the mysterious Dracula in York company Baron Productions’ account of Bram Stoker’s Gothic masterpiece in one of York’s most atmospheric churches.

When Jonathan Harker (Jack McAdam) embarks on a business trip to Count Dracula’s Transylvanian castle, little does he know the terror that awaits him. Guided by the wise Professor Van Helsing (Lee Gemmell), a courageous group must gamble their lives, even their very souls, to stop Dracula’s evil plans to enslave the world. Box office: ticketsource.co.uk/baron-productions. 

Pianist Ian Pace

Classical concert of the week: York Late Music presents The Beethoven Project: Ian Pace, Unitarian Chapel, St Saviourgate, April 5, 7.30pm

IN the second of The Beethoven Project concerts for York Late Music, pianist Ian Pace continues his exploration of Beethoven’s nine symphonies (transcribed by Franz Liszt) with his iconic Pastoral Symphony No. 6.

The programme also includes Michael Finnissy’s English Country Tunes (1-3), Beethoven’s Six Goethe-Lieder (transcribed by Liszt) and a new work of three musical tributes by Steve Crowther, Rock With Stock, A Study In Glass and Louis’ Angry Blues. Box office: latemusic.org/product/ian-pace-concert-tickets/ or on the door.

The poster for the new additions to Lightning Seeds’ Tomorrow’s Here Today 35 Years Greatest Hits Tour

Gig announcement of the week: Lightning Seeds, Tomorrow’s Here Today 35 Years Greatest Hits Tour, York Barbican, October 9, doors 7pm

LIVERPOOL singer, songwriter and producer Ian Broudie is extending Lightning Seeds’ 35th anniversary tour with 11 more dates this autumn. Here come Pure, The Life Of Riley, Change, Lucky You, Sense, All I Want, Sugar Coated Iceberg, You Showed Me, Emily Smiles, Three Lions and many more from his 20-track Tomorrow’s Here Today: 35 Years Of Lightning Seeds compilation album. This summer, Lightning Seeds will support York band Shed Seven at Millennium Square, Leeds, on July 11. Box office: yorkbarbican.co.uk.

Our Star Theatre Company’s tour poster for Hannay Stands Fast

In Focus: Our Star Theatre Company in Hannay Stands Fast, Joseph Rowntree Theatre, York

OUR Star Theatre Company cut a dash at the Joseph Rowntree Theatre, York, on Thursday and Friday in Hannay Stands Fast, the sequel to The 39 Steps.

Adapted by David Edgar from John Buchan’s novel, this rip-roaring comedy finds dashing hero Richard Hannay back in the fray on a mission to thwart a new and deadly threat to his beloved England.

Engaged on this top-secret case by MI5, Hannay makes his way down to Cornwall to infiltrate a secretive organisation and learn their dastardly plans. Can he save the day to keep the nation safe for another day? Cue derring-do, utter chaos and laughs aplenty in a show replete with a train, motorbike, ambulance, car, police vehicle, even a horse.

“Like for our production of The 39 Steps, Hannay Stands Fast is taken on by four actors playing dozens of characters – 53 to be precise! – set in various locations created through quick and innovative uses of trunks, crates, suitcases, ladders, you name it!” says director Ben Mowbray, who founded the Ledbury, Herefordshire company in 2016.

Our Star Theatre Company are visiting York on the debut UK tour of the British professional premiere of Hannay Stands Fast with a cast of George Cooper as Hannay and Angharad Mortimer in her company debut as Mary Lambington (and others), joined by the multi-role-playing Daniel Davies and Mowbray as First and Second Clown.

Our Star Theatre Company in Hannay Stands Fast, Joseph Rowntree Theatre, York, April 3 and 4, 7.30pm. Box office: 01904 501935 or josephrowntreetheatre.co.uk.