LOOK at these snippets from the reviews for Irish comedian Ed Byrne’s groundbreaking tour show, bound for the Grand Opera House, York, on January 11.
“Genuinely reflective and deeply emotional”. “Grief, regret”. “From rage to dark humour to poignancy”. “Dead funny”. “Cathartic storytelling”. “Tear-jerking observations”. “Poignant, touching, spiky”. “Plumbs the very depths of his soul”. “Delicate, sensitive high-wire act of a show”.
Just checking: this is a comedy gig, right? Yes indeed, one that takes its title from a quote from 19th century American writer, humorist, and essayist Mark Twain, who defined humour as “Tragedy Plus Time”.
Putting that metric to the test by mining the most tragic event in his life for humour, 52-year-old Byrne “manages to make dying and death very funny” (to quote the Daily Business Group review] in a show that carries the content warning “Discussions of death” with an age guidance of 14 plus.
At the time of this interview, Byrne, who grew up on the east coast of Ireland in Swords, County Dublin, had just finished a run of Irish dates where some had proved challenging, even for such an experienced act.
“The last night was a breeze, really, really good, not having to shut down drunken ****holes, but in Dunleary there was a noisy works outing and then four lads in Kilkenny on the front row that just wouldn’t shut up: one table of quite drunk people who I had to address for joining in too much,” Ed says.
“I don’t know if it [raucous behaviour] is on the increase, but with this show, it’s full of jokes but there are a couple of moments where it’s more serious, so you need some quiet, though it’s punctuated with a couple of laughs, but the last thing you want is someone who’s drunk to use that moment to butt in.”
Byrne’s material refracts the concept of Tragedy Plus Time through the prism of two ‘tragedies’. “One was my car being broken into, which I was raging about by the following night’s show. It was an enormous ball ache but I ended up with eight minutes of stand-up,” Ed says.
“The rest of the show is about how my brother Paul died [of Hodgkin’s lymphoma, a form of cancer, in February 2022, aged 44, after being diagnosed initially in 2013].” He had suffered a short illness in lockdown. “Then the Covid finished him off,” adds Ed.
“In the show I’m arguing with those who locked us down but at the same time didn’t take it seriously enough, and the reaction will depend on people’s political sensibilities.”
On stage, Byrne talks of how he argued with comedy director Paul, who he had called “my pain in the a*** little brother” in his 2022 tribute, but also of how he reconnected with him. “I will miss him so much,” his tribute had ended.
He is playing York as part of an extended tour that began in 2023, will visit Leeds City Varieties for the third time on January 25 and end in April 2025, almost two years after the first date. “My tours have been getting longer,” he says. “I always say that the hard part of the show is writing it and then getting out and doing it is the reward – and now there are just more and more places to play.
“When I was starting out, even playing a comedy night outside London in the Nineties, you were worried about how it would go because people had this idea of comedy as end of the pier and pub jokes, so observational comedy was something of an unknown quantity.
“I remember playing in Southend, where it was always one observational comedian and one end-of-the-pier comedian on the bill. Now, if people go and see a comedy club night, they know there’ll be some one-liners but a lot more storytelling, so you don’t feel like a visionary any more – and outside pantomime, comedy now draws the biggest audiences to theatres.”
Comedy has its broadest scope ever too, Byrne suggests. “I think people previously were perhaps slightly put off when they thought it was all going to be too political or too ‘ladsy’, but I think it’s a fact there is now comedy for everybody: whatever your demographic, race, creed, sexual orientation, there is humour designed just for you, comedy for all stripes,” Ed says.
He does add a note of caution, however: “The worrying thing is that it is becoming a bit polarised, and if a comedian is not tailored exactly to someone’s taste, they’ll say, ‘well, I’m not going to laugh at that’. I feel it’s post-Brexit where it’s become more divisive.”
As for Ed Byrne, he is breaking the unspoken barrier of death still being considered a taboo subject for conversation in Tragedy Plus Time, a show that has done anything but divide opinion. Oh, and for the record: “As with any subject I do, there are always digressions into asides,” he says.
Ed Byrne: Tragedy Plus Time, Grand Opera House, York, January 11, 7.30pm; Leeds City Varieties Music Hall, January 25, 7.30pm, and Cast, Doncaster, January 28, 7.30pm. Box office: York, atgtickets.com/york; Leeds, 0113 243 0808 or leedsheritagetheatres.com; Doncaster, 01302 303952 or castindoncaster.com.
Copyright of The Press, York